Updated: Apr 28
Assessing Ear competency
Students that show proficiency in using their ear to play the piano will progress faster and have more fun learning by ear. Always have a piece of music that you are reading each week in a lesson book, but spend most of the lesson (80%) teaching them to play by ear if that is their forte.
To assess whether they have a proficiency playing by ear, it could take 1 lesson, or 1 month. Sometimes it is clear just because the parent will say: ‘He has learned a few songs by ear.’ Or: ‘she doesn’t keep her eyes on the music when she plays, she just memorizes it.’ The key is not to make too many assumptions, but just try and see how well they respond to playing by ear, even trying to assign them songs to learn by ear, and asking them if they liked playing by ear more or if they liked playing the music on the page more. As a default, music reading is always a good fallback, as it is important to the parents for the child to learn to read. We’re only using this playing by ear as an option in case it helps them enjoy piano much more.
One way to assess if they have proficiency in playing by ear, is to have them close their eyes, you the teacher play a key, and see if they can guess which one you played. Don’t be surprised if they have to try it a few times and have you replay it a few times. The younger they are, the more narrow of key range you must give them as an option. For instance, if they are younger, you could tell them you will play one of the white notes from C to G. If they don’t know their musical alphabet yet, you could show them that you’re going to play one of the 5 black keys right by middle C, or even 1 of the 3 black keys. You could repeat this process a few times, and even try play 2 notes in a melody and see if they can play that back.
What to use
If you feel the student may be able to play something by ear, then you could consider assigning them something to play by ear. You would:
Ask for the family ipad or perhaps the parents smartphone or even the child’s smartphone (preferred) if they have one
Record a song at their appropriate level, rh and lh separately, then together. I like to label it thus: “twinkle rh”, “Twinkle lh” and twinkle “bh” to do twinkle twinkle little star with the rh, lh, and bh respectively.
Teach them how to use the ipad or phone to practice effectively
For mac products, use the search function to find the “voice memo” app.
This is the icon.
The ipad is easy to use because you can actually see the sound waves, and the student can use that visual to find a particular note or chord they want to figure out, and scrub through the sound a few times until they understand.
Teach them to RELY ON THEIR EARS. The biggest problem I have with students who have gifted ears, is that they will not be diligent and consistently listen to the recording to make sure they have it right. I tell them: when we read music, we rely on our EYES. So we don’t take our eyes off the music. When we learn music by ear, we rely on our EARS, so we don’t try to play it without listening to it many times daily.
If you press the “edit” button in the top right, you get this:
The red “replace” button is very useful for you. If say, you are recording something that is actually difficult to play, you can replace a mistake. You can also record a little bit of the song, press pause, and then resume recording in order to do it little by little.
The iphone app for voice memo has a few extra steps, but can do the same things.
Instruct the student to select the recording, press the 3 dots, select “edit Recording,” then you’ll get the 3rd screen. Instruct them NOT TO TOUCH THE REPLACE BUTTON, as that will record over your recording :) Tell them to tap the blue square symbol in the upper right, which will turn on the trim function.
You should now see the 3rd screen on the right. They could actually trim the audio file, but instruct them not to do so. Just have them use the play button and the sound waves to navigate the audio file.
If using the iphone, this is a WAY better way to do it then just pressing play from the first screen and trying to figure out the song, as the little slider is very difficult to use.
The student will need to go through the audio file NOTE BY NOTE sometimes. Make sure they understand that they need to go through one note at a time, or perhaps 1 chord at a time.
If they have android products, have them download an app called "awesome voice recorder." (AVR)
It functions similar to the voice memo app in that you can see the waves, which is important. You can also use this app if say you can't find the voice memo app on their iphone or ipad, as AVR is available for both android and apple.